Amish Affair

After leaving her own community, Hannah finds work and shelter in the home of Aaron, a charismatic Amish leader, where she cares for his sick wife. Although she feels a strong attraction to Aaron, she attempts to end their secret affair because she views the relationship as a sin. However, when the wife dies under suspicious circumstances, Hannah is accused of the crime and must fight to prove she is innocent.

This 2024 crime thriller was produced by Lifetime and Muse Entertainment as a TV movie. It was directed by Robin Hays, following her 2023 film How She Caught A Killer and preceding Danger in the Dorm, which also arrived in 2024. The screenplay was written by James Taylor Phillips. The film features Mackenzie Cardwell as Hannah and Ryan McPartlin as Aaron, with Maemae Renfrow, Evelyn Burke, Sebastian Greaves, and Dana Stoutenburg in supporting roles. The movie has a runtime of 86 minutes and is a joint production between Canada and the United States.